Moving from a planning calculator to running payroll means handling employee records, tax deposits, filings and payment deadlines. Use this guide to compare the capabilities your business needs.
Choose a service level
| Approach | What to check | Typical fit |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll calculations only | Who submits returns, deposits taxes and pays employees? | A business with payroll expertise in-house |
| Managed payroll software | Which federal, state and local filings are included? | Employers seeking automated recurring payroll |
| Accountant or payroll bureau | Scope of support, deadlines and responsibility for corrections | Businesses needing hands-on payroll support |
Compare the total cost
Ask for the base subscription, per-employee charges, additional-state charges, year-end forms, off-cycle payroll, contractor payments, implementation and cancellation terms. Compare a full year at your expected employee count.
Check coverage before price
Confirm support for the states and localities where employees work, applicable pay schedules, overtime, benefit deductions, garnishments, integrations and filing authorisations. Check how the provider handles rejected payments and tax notices.
Keep employer responsibilities clear
Using a payroll provider does not remove all employer responsibilities. Review IRS Publication 15 and confirm the duties you retain in your service agreement.
How this site handles commercial links
This guide contains no affiliate tracking links or paid rankings. If a future page includes a compensated relationship, it will disclose that relationship near the relevant links. No provider is presented here as personally tested.
Keep exploring your pay
FIND YOUR NEXT CALCULATION
One place for your pay questions.
Convert a salary, estimate a paycheck or check how a bonus changes your deposit.