PayrollCalculator

How to Check a Payslip for Common Errors

Written by

in

A payslip is a set of numbers that should reconcile with each other. You do not need to understand every rule behind it to spot something that has gone wrong — most errors show up as arithmetic that does not quite work. The routine below takes a few minutes and is worth doing each period rather than once a year.

Last reviewed: 27 Oct 2026 (Europe/London). Tax year context: US federal employment taxes for 2026. This page is an estimate aid, not tax advice.

Start with the headline figures

Find your gross pay for the period, your total deductions and your net pay. Before checking anything else, confirm the relationship between them: gross pay minus total deductions should equal net pay. If that does not hold, the error is somewhere in the figures themselves rather than in a rate or an allowance, and payroll can usually trace it quickly. For how gross and net relate, see gross pay and net pay.

Check hours and rates behind gross pay

Gross pay should reflect the hours you actually worked. Compare the hours shown against your own record of shifts, overtime and any paid leave. Watch for overtime recorded at the basic rate, hours that failed to carry over from a timesheet, or a period where a pay change should have taken effect but did not. If your gross pay is a fixed salary, the amount should still match the figure you expect for that period, including any agreed adjustment. A simple conversion from annual salary to a period amount is in how to convert an annual salary.

Work through the deductions line by line

Deductions are where errors are easiest to miss, because they are often taken automatically. Read each line and ask whether you expect it to be there this period. Look for a deduction appearing twice, a deduction that should have stopped, a pension or benefit contribution that does not match the amount you elected, or a recovery for something you have already repaid. If a line is unfamiliar, note it down rather than guessing at its purpose.

On a US payslip, common federal lines include federal income tax withholding (from Form W-4 and the methods in IRS Publication 15-T) and Social Security and Medicare (FICA) withholding. For 2026, IRS Topic 751 and Publication 15 (Circular E) both state the employee Social Security rate as 6.2% and the employee Medicare rate as 1.45% of covered wages (employer matches those rates). Social Security applies only up to the annual wage base; Medicare has no wage base. Additional Medicare Tax of 0.9% may also appear once wages exceed the employer withholding threshold described in Topic 751.

If the Social Security or Medicare lines look wrong, our guide to FICA taxes: Social Security and Medicare withholding shows how each is calculated, with worked examples.

Compare year-to-date figures

Year-to-date figures should build on the previous payslip. Take last period’s year-to-date gross and add this period’s gross; the result should equal the new year-to-date figure. Repeat for deductions. A jump that does not follow from this period’s activity usually means an earlier period has been restated or a payment has been posted twice. Year-to-date Social Security wages should stop increasing once they reach the annual Social Security wage base for the year (for earnings in 2026, Topic 751 and Pub. 15 both list $184,500).

Match boxes you will see later on Form W-2

Your year-end Form W-2 summarises wages and federal tax withheld. Box meanings are defined in the IRS instructions for Form W-2 (for example Box 1 wages, Box 2 federal income tax withheld, Boxes 3–6 for Social Security and Medicare wages and tax). If a payslip line never appears in the matching W-2 box, ask payroll before filing. See About Form W-2 and the current General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3.

What to do if something does not add up

Contact payroll in writing, quoting the pay period and the specific line that looks wrong. Explain the arithmetic you expected and how you reached it. Keep the payslip and your own records until the query is resolved. Payroll teams see these questions routinely, and a precise query is far quicker to resolve than a general one. For a forward-looking estimate of federal withholding, the IRS publishes the Tax Withholding Estimator — use it alongside, not instead of, your own payslip check.

Sources (official)

Open the Paycheck Calculator